‘It’s Been a Sh*tshow’ — Esports Casters Call for Change After Embark Studios Replaces Talent for The Finals’ Grand Major Qualifier Highlight Reel With Game’s AI Commentators
ign.com Nov 18, 2026

‘It’s Been a Sh*tshow’ — Esports Casters Call for Change After Embark Studios Replaces Talent for The Finals’ Grand Major Qualifier Highlight Reel With Game’s AI Commentators

AI-summarised brief · reviewed before publication

Embark Studios sparked controversy after it posted, then deleted, a highlight reel of The Finals’ Grand Major APAC Closed Qualifiers that replaced the live esports casters with the game’s fictional AI commentators, Scotty and June. The AI narration quoted the original casters, prompting outrage from commentators such as Proto/Kai, Bluepanda, and LemonKiwi, who accused the studio of erasing their work and using their voices without consent. The backlash spread across the esports community, with critics calling the move “devious” and “embarrassing.” Embark explained the decision as an effort to leverage familiar in‑game characters for broader audience appeal, but later admitted the omission was a misstep, removed the video, and pledged not to repeat the format for future regional recaps. The studio’s statement emphasized gratitude for the “candid feedback” from talent.

💡 Why It Matters

  • · Replacing human casters with AI undermines the labor that gives esports its personality, threatening the credibility of broadcast talent and prompting calls for industry standards on AI use.